Reviews for WD Caviar Green WD10EACS 1 TB Internal Hard Drive

Great drive for the money

Strengths: Low cost, high capacity, solid performance

Weakness: Not the fastest (if you care about that sort of thing)

Western Digital has really hit a home run with this drive. It's by far the cheapest 1TB drive on the market (typically $25-$75 than the others), it's very quiet, and out of the 6 I've purchased in the last two months NONE have had any problems.

It also consumes less power, meaning it produces less heat. It does so through a variety of technologies but also (mainly) because the drive spins slower than competitors. But don't let this fact dissuade you, as the drive 1) is still very fast 2) the speed won't make any difference if you are putting it an external enclosure (USB/FireWire become the bottlenecks there) and 3) the penalty will only be noticed [maybe] if you are running it in a RAID where every millisecond of performance matters.

A great buy!

100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

1TB at a good price

Strengths: Drive runs quiet and cool, 3 yr warranty

Weakness: 16 mb cache - slightly slower perf

Drive was easy to set up and runs quiet and cool at 5400 rpm. Green drive saves on power and runs perfectly in the NAS box in RAID 1 config with a small tradeoff in performance (not your best option for a boot drive).

100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

No problems but make sure you cool it!

Strengths: Large size and dependable.

Weakness: Can run a bit hot, so make sure to have some good cooling.

I loaded my harddrive into an Antec MX-1 active cooled enclosure and backed up all of my data onto it. I think it would have been running pretty hot if I didn't have it in the active-cooled enclosure. Also, not using the SATA connection makes the data transfer a bit slow (through USB).

100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Storage Solution.

Strengths: big, cheap, quiet, efficient

Weakness: it is what it is. not for very high performance, lower rpm than other 1tb drives to save energy, but as far as storage and hd video playback go, it\\\'s great.

I\\\'m playing large HD (.mkv) media files in Vista without a problem. It\\\'s nice and quiet on my media center pc. I don\\\'t use it for anything else. I\\\'m no hard drive expert, but as far as looking for a nice, big, quiet drive to shove into the 3.5 spot in your case, it\\\'s a beauty. after losing many files thanks to externals, I\\\'m happy to put something in that\\\'s a little safer and efficient. apparently it saves energy by only moving the rpm\\\'s up to the level they need to be. averages, i read, are about 5400, but i guess it can max at 7200 if need be. i wouldn\\\'t suggest for gaming performance, maybe not even to run an os on, but as far as storage goes, i\\\'m in love.

92% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Solid Product

Strengths: Large Size, 3 Year Warranty, Runs Quiet and Cool. Perfect drive for Media Center storage.

Weakness: Not so great performance.

Western Digital again delivers a good quality product. Many people may complain about the performance of these drives though. It's a variable speed drive which many people may not like for their main desktop drive.

These drives are the future, so get used too it. Most drives made in the past few years have the ability to be slowed down for heat/energy/sound issues. It's just that the option wasn't easily adjustable by consumers. (Google "Automatic Acoustic Management")

I purchased four of these for use in a Media File Server which will be running 24/7. The reduced power usage (up to almost 50% over other drives) and the reduction in heat that goes with it is what encouraged me to purchase these.

Compare the energy consumption on WD's site and you'll see these drives use about the same amount of power as a 120-250GB drive.

If you are interested in speed, you might consider some other product.

50% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

WD Caviar GP 1TB Hard Drive (Serial ATA-300, 16MB

Strengths: Very good packaging, seems it is a factory sealed

Weakness: I do not see any weaknesses yet.

Very good value for a money paid.As it was promiced by site, it is a new, factory sealed 1 Tb internal hard drive bundled with full back up software.I hope it will work the way it was described.

0% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Excellent drive

Strengths: Has not failed me! Holds a lot of stuff!

Weakness: Heats up pretty well

This is a great drive and will provide plenty of storage for my needs for the time being. I have it in an Antex MX1 enclosure so in terms of overheating, the enclosure is doing a good job 'dissipating' the heat. I haven't been able to tell of any degraded performance either. I've already filled out 75% of the drive!

Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Western Digital Caviar Green 1TB SATA300 WD10EACS

Testseek.com has collected 21 expert reviews for Western Digital Caviar Green 1TB SATA300 WD10EACS and the average expert rating is 74 of 100. The average score reflects the expert community’s view on this product. Click below and use Testseek.com to see all ratings, product awards and conclusions.

Read Full Review